Posted by Lou on January 31, 2010, 7:41 pm
>> You've lost me. How do you demonstrate it to yourself?
>The next time you are in the midst of a cold/flu or are heading that
>way start on bicarbonate as described above, keeping it well away from
>meals, coffee, acidic juices and sodas.
Oh, I have no doubt you'll get better. People all but always recover from a
cold, by far most people recover from the flu, and everyone has experienced
early symptoms and managed to avoid coming down with a full blown case of
the illness. The thing is, this happens whether or not the patient swallows
bicarbonate.
Remember when Linus Pauling said that large does of vitamin C could prevent
a cold, or shorten its duration, or mitagate the symptoms? How many people
followed his advice, how many people swore it worked? 30 trials such as I
outlined, spread among 10,000 patients have been carried out. No reduction
in the severity of symptoms have been observed, and no significant reduction
in the risk of catching a cold has been found, except in people in extreme
circumstances (like soldiers engaged in sub-arctic exercises, skiers, and
marathon runners). No significant benefits have been observed when starting
to take vitamin C after the onset of symptoms.
That doesn't mean that bicarbonate doesn't work. But your subjective
experience, however suggestive, isn't proof.
Posted by Courtney on February 1, 2010, 11:03 pm
> No significant benefits have been observed when starting
> to take vitamin C after the onset of symptoms.
> That doesn't mean that bicarbonate doesn't work. But your subjective
> experience, however suggestive, isn't proof.
Numerous times I have also found that though I can sometimes dampen
out a cold, in its early stages with vitamin C; once the cold is
underway C seems to have little effect.
This is why I was so intrigued by my experience with bicarbonate. I
was right in the midst of a severe cold and from the first dose the
cold was dampened and then tapered out. I have a sister out west who
is having a similar experience with a cold.
I'm not offering this as "proof." Just offering my experience. Those
who may have "ears to hear" may wish to give it a try - all others
feel free to disregard.
Posted by Rod Speed on January 24, 2010, 9:20 pm
Courtney wrote:
> Testimonials:
> My father was a veterinarian and as far back as I can remember (I was
> born in 1938 so my memory goes back to maybe 1943) he would take
> sodium bicarbonate dissolved in a full glass of warm water whenever he
> felt a cold coming on. I don’t remember him ever coming down with a
> full blown cold.
I dont either, and I dont bother to do anything special to ward them off.
Its likely some medical effect.
I used to, but it stopped once I was about 25 or so.
> He would treat my cold symptoms likewise and I responded equally as well.
> He also treated farm animals for various illnesses with sodium bicarbonate
> via a gastric tube and they recovered quickly. So I’ve known about the
> benefits of sodium bicarbonate from early childhood on. Glad to see
> that its benefits are being more widely touted. Although my father was a
doctor of
> Veterinarian medicine, he sometimes referred to himself as an MD (Mule Doctor).
> Dr. David B Winter, DO
>The next time you are in the midst of a cold/flu or are heading that
>way start on bicarbonate as described above, keeping it well away from
>meals, coffee, acidic juices and sodas.